I personally haven't seen this much carbon build up before, but I know it can't be normal. I took my engine out to fix some seals that were leaking, one including some seepage coming from the head gasket. As soon as I took the head off from the block I saw lots of carbon built deposits on top of one of the pistons. Looks like piston #4 if I'm not mistaken. Before I took the engine out of the car, I saw some soot spit out from the tail pipe on cold starts and black smoke when hitting Vtec at full throttle. The last time I did a compression test, I had 165 across all four. What could have caused this?